Extreme winter weather still threatens Texas’ electric grid, ERCOT assessment finds

But some analysts say the state’s grid operator is still being overly optimistic about the weather and what it will mean for electricity demand.

By Mose Buchele, KUT; radio interview produced by Jill AmentNovember 22, 2021 10:32 am, , ,

From KUT:

Lee esta historia en español.

The Texas grid should run smoothly under normal winter conditions, but extreme weather could still pitch Texans into darkness, according to an assessment released Friday by the Electric Reliability Council of Texas.

The report, known as a Seasonal Assessment of Resource Adequacy, says the grid is well positioned to supply enough power to meet demand under normal and moderately challenging winter conditions. But extreme weather could cause increased electricity demand while causing breakdowns along the energy supply chain, resulting in blackouts.

How are you preparing for this coming winter? Leave us a voice memo.

The assessments, released four times a year, are based on a number of assumptions about energy supply, demand and likely weather conditions. They can often raise more questions than they answer.

This time around, some analysts say, the state’s grid operator is being overly optimistic about the weather and what it will mean for electricity demand (often referred to as “load”).

“We expect there’s a 10% chance that demand will exceed what ERCOT considers to be their extreme peak load scenario,” Andrew Dessler, a professor of atmospheric sciences at Texas A&M who has been researching the grid, told KUT. “In my opinion that’s not a great worst-case scenario. One in 10 things happen all the time.”

Others have questioned whether ERCOT is underestimating how much power generation could break down in another deep freeze, including freeze-offs in the natural gas supply chain.

Those two factors, supply and demand, are crucial to maintaining the reliability of the grid. If they fall out of balance, ERCOT is forced to take measures, including widespread power cuts, to restore balance on the system.

It was an effort to restore that balance to the grid that led ERCOT to cut power to millions for days during February’s winter storm.

ERCOT’s assessment comes on the heels of another report from the North American Electric Reliability Corp. that found the Texas grid remains vulnerable to blackouts in the event of another big winter storm.

If you found the reporting above valuable, please consider making a donation to support it here. Your gift helps pay for everything you find on texasstandard.org and KUT.org. Thanks for donating today.