Teacher resignations drive teacher shortage in San Antonio

‘Your teachers are not OK. They need help. They need support, be it financial, emotional — your teachers are not OK.’

By Camille Phillips, TPRNovember 14, 2022 10:45 am, ,

From Texas Public Radio:

This is the first in a three-part series on San Antonio’s teacher shortage. Read part two and part three.

Erin Deason had to fill more teacher vacancies this year than she’s had to fill in any other year in her nearly two decades as principal of Jackson Middle School on San Antonio’s near North East side.

Seventeen of her teachers quit or retired at the end of last school year, but she considers herself lucky because she was able to fill 15 of those vacancies by the time school started in August.

“There are some schools that still have a lot of teacher vacancies. I’ve been lucky with it just being the two,” said Deason.

Jackson started the school year short two special education teachers and five instructional assistants. A couple of weeks in, they also lost their librarian.

Camille Phillips / Texas Public Radio

Jackson Middle School Principal Erin Deason stands outside the school's closed library Aug. 24, 2022. They lost their librarian a few weeks into the school year and had to close the room until someone could be found to run it.

On a tour of the school, Deason pointed out the library’s locked doors.

“We’re hoping to get that position filled pretty quickly so we can get kids in there,” Deason said. “Typically, it’s a pretty active place.”

Deason said the biggest impact of her vacancies — besides the locked-up library — are a few larger classes and an additional responsibility added to some teachers’ schedules. Because they don’t have enough instructional assistants, teachers are providing a second pair of hands in those classes instead.

“Since COVID came we just all take on extra stuff – it’s just part of the job, I think,” Deason said. “And so, I always want to make sure that my staff that’s here and working every day is not having a lot more put onto them.”

One of the reasons San Antonio is struggling to find enough teachers this school year is that many districts saw a spike in resignations at the end of last school year. Districts struggled to fill all of their vacancies last fall, but this year they have even more vacancies.

Jackson is in the North East Independent School District, which had twice the normal number of teacher resignations at the end of the 2021-2022 school year.

“In 2018 it was like 334,” said Chyla Whitton, North East ISD’s director of human resources. “In 2021 It was 361. So, not a huge difference — kind of on trend with what we’ve seen. This year, we went up to over 700 resignations.”

North East isn’t the only district that had such unusually high turnover. According to a TPR analysis of data from a dozen San Antonio school districts, 56% more teachers quit this summer than they did the year before. That left San Antonio schools with more than a thousand more vacancies to fill this summer.

Why? It’s no secret that teacher morale is low.

Billy Cano quit teaching this year nine weeks into the school year. He was a 12-year veteran at Krueger Middle School, also at North East ISD.

“The mistake I made was that I knew. I knew I was done last year, and I should have never signed the contract for this year,” said Cano. “Your teachers are not OK. They need help. They need support, be it financial, emotional — your teachers are not OK.”

Cano is an instructional coach and a department chair for English and Language Arts. In a normal year, he said he would at most teach two classes so that he has time to support other teachers. But this year his department had three vacancies and he was teaching five classes.

Camille Phillips / Texas Public Radio

Billy Cano sits at the table in his kitchen where he used to do hours of administrative work for his job as an instructional coach at a North East ISD middle school.

“I was able to do it when it was two classes,” said Cano. “But these additional classes that were there, it exhausted me.”

Cano said he spent hours every night working on the administrative duties he didn’t have time to accomplish during the day, but the final straw for him was when his father had a health scare and ended up in the hospital.

Because his department is already short three teachers and it’s so hard to find substitutes right now, Cano didn’t feel like he could take time off to visit his dad.

“When you make teachers do so much, you’re now pitting the guilt of them abandoning their fellow teachers and the children they teach against the guilt of not spending time with their families,” Cano said. “At some point, the families are going to win. And that’s what happened with me.”

Two surveys of Texas teachers released earlier this year warned that a huge swath of teachers was thinking about quitting. The turnover data in San Antonio shows they followed through.

Now districts have to figure out how they can convince more of them to stay in the classroom.

If you found the reporting above valuable, please consider making a donation here. Your gift helps pay for everything you find on texasstandard.org and Texas Public Radio. Thanks for donating today.